ÉTAT HER

Johnny Marr on The Smiths' Breakup: Paul McCartney's Line Became His Go-To Answer

After The Smiths split in 1987, Johnny Marr spent an entire day with Paul and Linda McCartney and walked away with one line — "That's bands" — that's served as his standard answer to the question ever since.

Johnny Marr on The Smiths' Breakup: Paul McCartney's Line Became His Go-To Answer

In July 1987, Johnny Marr left The Smiths. Guitar duties briefly passed to former Easterhouse member Ivor Perry, but Perry didn't click with Morrissey, and by the time the Manchester legends' fourth and final album, "Strangeways, Here We Come," came out that September, the band was already effectively over.

In a recent MOJO interview, Marr looked back on that chaotic period and brought up an unexpected key figure: Paul McCartney.

Marr said he spent "a long, incredible day" with Paul and Linda McCartney. Linda was warm and kept asking about his life; when it was McCartney's turn, Marr laid out the whole story of the band's breakup. "I looked at him, waiting for a response, and all he said was: 'That's bands.'" Marr called it "a brilliant answer" — one he's pulled out ever since whenever people come to him for life advice. Sometimes, things just don't need overthinking.

That meeting was more than just a chat. In a 2012 interview with The Auto Jubilator, Marr shared details: the two never formally hit a recording studio, but spent a full eight or nine hours "just playing and playing, hard and loud." He described McCartney as "a great bass player, a great singer" — this was the first thing he did after The Smiths broke up, and "it was a happy time." The two crossed paths occasionally after that, but never played together again. "He was always very friendly, very gracious."

For Marr, that "that's bands" line ended up shaping his career choices in a way. He admitted he wasn't in a rush to form another band after the split, and was happy instead to work as a supporting guitarist for various artists: Matt Johnson of The The has been a close friend for years, and he cherished collaborations with New Order's Bernard Sumner, the Pretenders' Chrissie Hynde, and later recording sessions with Bryan Ferry. "If you wrote all that down as a résumé, it'd look like I was just drifting from gig to gig, but I knew a good job when I had one. Some things don't need overthinking."

This memory resurfaced just as The Smiths made fresh news. Earlier this month, Rough Trade announced "Rough Trade 45s: Volume 2," a vinyl box set featuring newly pressed classic singles from label acts including The Fall, Aztec Camera, Mazzy Star, Scritti Politti, and Robert Wyatt, limited to 1,000 copies and set for release on October 30. Among them is a Smiths single hand-picked by Morrissey and Marr themselves: "The Headmaster Ritual" on the A-side and "I Want The One I Can't Have" on the B-side. Both tracks originally appeared on the 1985 album "Meat Is Murder" but were never released as a single through Rough Trade — this marks their debut as a proper single.

Related

Downey's Doctor Doom Blocks Stormbreaker Bare-Handed in New Avengers: Doomsday Trailer
Entertainment

Downey's Doctor Doom Blocks Stormbreaker Bare-Handed in New Avengers: Doomsday Trailer

Robert Downey Jr.'s Doctor Doom catches Thor's hammer with his bare hand and summons Sentinel robots — the second trailer unveiled at D23 pushes "Avengers: Doomsday"'s villain to a whole new level.

Lionel Richie Jokes, Then Walks It Back: "They're Devout Christians"
Entertainment

Lionel Richie Jokes, Then Walks It Back: "They're Devout Christians"

During his own tour with Earth, Wind & Fire, Lionel Richie poked fun at Usher and Chris Brown's "R&B Tour," saying "we've never been to prison" — the crowd laughed, and he scrambled to walk it back.

A Photo Captioned "5.": Fontaines D.C. Tease New Album With Two Unfinished Demos
Entertainment

A Photo Captioned "5.": Fontaines D.C. Tease New Album With Two Unfinished Demos

The Dublin band posted a black-and-white photo on Instagram with just "5." as the caption. Just before that, they'd debuted two wildly different new songs at their comeback show in Cádiz.

Disney Announces "Kingdom Hearts" Animated Series, Protagonist May Not Be Sora
Entertainment

Disney Announces "Kingdom Hearts" Animated Series, Protagonist May Not Be Sora

The teaser silhouette revealed at the D23 presentation sparked fan discussion—who is this character holding a Keyblade? Disney confirmed the animated series will be an entirely new story, with Tetsuya Nomura personally involved in development.

Stitch's Girlfriend Angel Goes Live-Action: D23 Reveals Look and 2028 Release Date
Entertainment

Stitch's Girlfriend Angel Goes Live-Action: D23 Reveals Look and 2028 Release Date

Disney dropped the first wave of intel on the live-action "Lilo & Stitch 2" at D23, confirming Experiment 624, aka "Angel," is officially joining the cast. Original voice actor and co-creator Chris Sanders is back in the director's chair, with the film set to hit theaters May 28, 2028.

Sziget Night Four: BMTH Builds an Apocalyptic Theater, Rose Gray Closes with Just a Mirror
Entertainment

Sziget Night Four: BMTH Builds an Apocalyptic Theater, Rose Gray Closes with Just a Mirror

On Day 4 of Sziget Festival 2026 in Budapest, Bring Me The Horizon rolled out a full-scale apocalyptic spectacle, while Rose Gray compressed an entire night into one hour. Skepta, Nia Archives, and Peggy Gou each held down their own corner of the fest.